8th Annual VES Awards

Saturday, February 21, 2009
Hyatt Regency Century Plaza Hotel
Century City, CA

8th annual awards thumbnail

Filmmakers, producers and guests joined more than a thousand attendees from the visual effects industry for the sold-out gala which honored and James Cameron with the VES Lifetime Achievement Award and and Dr. Ed Catmull with the Georges Méliès Award for Pioneering.

and Avatar was the evening’s big winner taking home six awards including Outstanding Visual Effects in a Visual Effects Driven Motion Picture. The animated feature film and Up was honored with three awards including Outstanding Animation in an Animated Feature Motion Picture. The 2010 VES Awards premiered on Friday, March 5, 2010 on REELZCHANNEL.

Honorees

JJ Abrams
Lifetime Achievement Award

James Cameron

Awarded for significant and lasting contributions to the art and science of the visual effects industry by way of vision, artistry, invention and innovation.

JJ Abrams
Georges Méliès Award

Ed Catmull

Awarded for pioneering significant and lasting contributions to the art and science of the visual effects industry by way of artistry, invention and groundbreaking work.

Highlights

JJ Abrams Speech
James Cameron’s Lifetime Achievement Award Speech

James Cameron receives the Lifetime Achievement Awards at the 8th Annual VES Awards.

Zoe Saldana Speech
Steven Spielberg Introduces VES Student Award

Steven Spielberg thanks Autodesk and the Visual Effects Society for making the VES student award a reality, and congratulates the students for their outstanding work.

Winners & Nominees

Below is the complete list of Winners and Nominees for the 8th Annual VES Awards. A sortable list for ALL years of VES Award winners / nominees can be found on the Previous VES Awards page. All archival viewing materials are cleared for viewing by logged-in VES members behind the VES website firewall. For more information, please review the VES Awards Rules & Procedures, Section 14: Ownership & Clearances here.

View the category of the nominees and winners below.

Outstanding Visual Effects in a Visual Effects-Driven Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the visual effects within a live action motion picture where the visual effects are a visible, essential, and integral part of the story and play a principal and active role in the motion picture. A rule of thumb for defining whether a motion picture would be considered effects-driven would be to ask if the story could be told without the active participation of the VFX (including Special Effects). On the whole, the VFX in an effects-driven film would be easily identifiable by the viewing public and professionals working in the VFX field.

Fully animated films are not eligible in this category.

2012

Volker Engel
Marc Weigert
Josh Jaggars


Avatar (Winner)

Joe Letteri
Joyce Cox
Eileen Moran
Richard Baneham


District 9

Dan Kaufman
Stefanie Boose
James Stewart
Peter Muyzers


Star Trek

Roger Guyett
Burt Dalton
Shari Hanson
Russell Earl


Transformers – Revenge of The Fallen

Scott Farrar
John Frazier
Scott Benza
Wayne Billheimer


Outstanding Supporting Visual Effects in a Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the visual effects within a live action motion picture where the visual effects play a supporting, minor or background role in the telling of the story. Supporting visual effects, when taken as a whole, may help create the setting, environment, or mood of an entire film, but are generally intended to be subtle or invisible to the lay viewer. They do not consist of a significant number of CG characters, science fiction or fantasy elements, and other highly visible effects that one would expect to see in a visual effects-driven or “tent pole” film.

Effects-driven films may not enter their “invisible” effects in this category, and animated films are not eligible.

Angels & Demons

Barrie Hemsley
Angus Bickerton
Ryan Cook
Mark Breakspear

Invictus

Michael Owens
Geoff Hancock
Cyndi Ochs
Dennis Hoffman


Sherlock Holmes (Winner)

Jonathan Fawkner
Chas Jarrett
David Vickery
Dan Barrow


The Box

Thomas Tannenberger
Olcun Tan
Mark Kolpak
Peter Cvijanovic


The Road

Mark O. Forker
Phillip Moses
Ed Mendez
Paul Graff


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Broadcast Miniseries, Movie, or Special

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the visual effects within a single episode of an effects-driven miniseries, made-for-television movie or special that was broadcast and delivered via over-the-air, pay/basic cable, or satellite transmissions to homes. A rule of thumb for defining whether a program would be considered effects-driven would be to ask if the story could be told without the active participation of the VFX (including Special Effects).

Alice – Night 2

Lee Wilson
Lisa Sepp-Wilson
Sebastien Bergeron
Les Quinn


Ben 10: Alien Swarm – Montage

Evan Jacobs
Sean McPherson
Andrew Orloff


Disney Prep and Landing – Gadgets, Globes, and other Garish Gizmos (Winner)

Dorothy McKim
Scott Kersavage
David Hutchins
Kee Suong


Infestation

PJ Foley
Efram Potelle
James May
Dan DeEntremont


Skellig

Sara Bennett
Jenna Powell
David Houghton
Jean-Claude Deguara


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Broadcast Series

This award is to honor the achievement of the visual effects within a single episode of a series where the visual effects are a visible, essential, and integral part of the story and play a principal and active role in the show. A rule of thumb for defining whether a series would be considered effects-driven would be to ask if the story could be told without the active participation of the VFX (including Special Effects).

Battlestar Galactica season 4 – Ep. 421 “Daybreak” (Winner)

Michael Gibson
Gary Hutzel
Jesse Toves
Dave Morton


Defying Gravity – Pilot

Sam Nicholson
Dale Fay
Mike Yip
Jared Jones


Fringe – Ep. 206 “Earthling”

Jay Worth
Robert Habros
Andrew Orlaff
Eric Hance

Stargate Universe – Air

Mark Savela
Shannon Gurney
Andrew Karr
Craig Vandenbiggelaar


V – Pilot

Andrew Orloff
Karen Czukerberg
Chris Zapara
Johnathan R. Banta

Outstanding Supporting Visual Effects in a Broadcast Program

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the visual effects that play a supporting or background role within a single episode of a broadcast series, miniseries, made-for-television movie, or special wherein the visual effects are not necessarily essential to the telling of the story in the way that the effects of an effects-driven broadcast program are. Supporting visual effects, when taken as a whole, may help create the setting, environment, or mood of an entire program, and are generally intended to be invisible to the lay viewer. They do not consist of a significant number of CG characters, science fiction or fantasy elements, and other highly visible effects that one would expect to see in a visual effectsdriven broadcast program.

CSI Crime Scene Investigation – Ep. 1001 “Opening Sequence” (Winner)

Rik Shorten
Sabrina Arnold
Steve Meyer
Derek Smith

Flash Forward – No More Good Days

Kevin Blank
Andrew Orloff
Steve Meyer
Jonathan Spencer Levy


Kings – Ep. 001 “Goliath”

Craig Weiss
Ron Moore
Niel Wray
Brian Vogt

Krupp-Eine Deutsche Familie – Krupp

Thomas Tannenberger
Olcun Tan
Mark Kolpak
Shane Cook


Lost – The Incident Part 1 & 2

Mitch Suskin
Samantha Mabie-Tuinstra
Eric Hance
Sean Scott

Best Single Visual Effect of the Year

2012 – Escape from L.A.

Volker Engel
Marc Weigert
Josh R. Jaggars
Mohen Leo


Avatar – Quarich’s Escape

John Knoll
Jill Brooks
Frank Losasso Petterson
Tory Mercer


Avatar- Neytiri Drinking (Winner)

Joe Letteri
Joyce Cox
Eileen Moran
Thelvin Cabezas


Knowing – Plane Crash

Andrew Jackson
Camille Cellucci
Dan Breckwoldt
Angelo Sahin


Terminator Salvation – VLA Escape

Charles Gibson
Chantal Feghali
Ben Snow
Susan Greenhow


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Commercial

AMF – The Caterpillar

Asher Edwards
Robert Sethi
Becky Porter
Jamie O’Hara


Audi – Intelligently Combined (Winner)

Jay Barton
Rafael F. Colon
Ronald Herbst
Chris Fieldhouse


Kerry LowLow – Mouse

Jake Mengers
Stephen Newbold
Ashley Bernes
Louisa Cartwright Tucker


Pepsi – The Flight of the Penguin

Murray Butler
Seth Gollub
Andy Walker
Jenn Dewey


Plane Stupid – Polar Bears

Jake Mengers
Vicky Osborn
Suzanne Jandu
Scott Griffin


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Special Venue Project

The award is to honor the overall achievement of the visual effects within an entire Special Venue project. Special Venues are defined as installations specifically set up to project large-format films (e.g. IMAX or OMNIMAX theaters), theme park theaters that may include a motion-based ride, museums, World Fairs, and similar venues.

To be eligible, a Special Venue project must have been exhibited publicly:

  • In a commercial venue for a paid admission, which may include the general admission to a theme park or special venue theater;
  • For a minimum period of one week on a regular daily schedule; and
  • Premiered in the current awards year in a Special Venue theater as defined above.

The following are not eligible in this category, regardless of the material’s original capture format:

  • Special purpose events such as trade shows and conventions;
  • Video material generally referred to as “pre-show” material;
  • Repurposed films, i.e. projects initially intended for the theatrical market but which have been blown up for exhibition in large-format Special Venue theaters;
  • Projects that were created as conventional 2D theatrical presentations but have been repurposed to stereographic 3D;
  • Any 2D or stereographic 3D feature motion picture that either premiered first, or simultaneously, in any regular movie theater or in any broadcast medium;
  • Any project that runs for an equal or greater amount of time in any regular movie theater or in any broadcast medium; and
  • Movies intended for simultaneous distribution in both Special Venue and normal movie theaters. The intent of this category is to honor those projects made specifically for the Special Venue market.

Beyond All Boundaries – Multi-plane Visual Effects

Daren Ulmer
Cedar Conner
Susan Beth Smith


Dance Of The Dragons – Eastern (Winner)

Derry Frost
Michael Morreale


Outstanding Animation in an Animated Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the animation within an entire animated motion picture. The animation may be created by traditional cel animation, computer animation, and/or stop motion, as long as it meets the definitions of Animation and Animated Project as stated in the Appendix of this Rules & Procedures. The vocal performance of characters may be taken into consideration along with the visual qualities in evaluating the overall effectiveness of the animation.Title sequences are not eligible in this category.

9

Jinko Gotoh
Joe Ksander
Daryl Graham
Ken Duncan


Cloudy With a Chance Of Meatballs

Pete Nash
Chris Juen
Alan Hawkins
Mike Ford


Coraline

Henry Selick
Claire Jennings


Ice Age – Dawn Of The Dinosaurs

Melvin Tan
Galen Chu
Jeff Gabor
Anthony Nisi

Up (Winner)

Pete Docter
Jonas Rivera
Steve May
Gary Bruins


Outstanding Animated Character in a Live Action Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement in a single animated character in a live action motion picture. The character may have been created by any technique or combination of techniques, including animatronics, as long as it meets the definition of Animation as stated in the Glossary of these Rules & Procedures.

Title sequences are not eligible in this category.

Avatar – Neytiri (Winner)

Joe Letteri
Andrew R. Jones
Jeff Unay
Zoe Saldana


District 9 – Christopher Johnson

Steve Nichols
Jeremy Mesana
Vera Zivny
Brett Ineson


G-Force – Bucky

Benjamin Cinelli
Dustin Wicke
Peter Tieryas
Ryan Yee


Watchmen – Doctor Manhattan

Keith Smith
Kevin Hudson
Victor Schutz
Aaron Campbell


Outstanding Animated Character in an Animated Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement in a single animated character in an animated motion picture. The character may have been created by any technique or combination of techniques, including animatronics, as long as it meets the definition of Animation as stated in the Glossary.

Title sequences are not eligible in this category.

Coraline – ‘Coraline’

Travis Knight
Trey Thomas

Ice Age – Dawn Of The Dinosaurs – Buck

Simon Pegg
Peter de Seve

Monsters Vs. Aliens – B.O.B.

David Burgess
Scott Cegielski
Terran Boylan
David Weatherly


UP – Carl – “No Dad Scene” (Winner)

Ed Asner
Ron Zorman
Brian Tindall
Carmen Ngai


Outstanding Animated Character in a Broadcast Program or Commercial

This award is to honor the overall achievement in a single animated character in a broadcast program or commercial. The character may have been created by any technique or combination of techniques, including animatronics, as long as it meets the definition of Animation as stated in the Glossary. The character may or may not be photorealistic.

Title sequences are not eligible in this category.

AMF – The Caterpillar (Winner)

Robert Sethi
Jamie O’Hara
Becky Porter
Steve Beck


Disney Prep and Landing – Wayn

David Foley
Mark Mitchell
Hidetaka Yosumi
Leo Sanchez Barbosa


Evian – Skating Babies

Jorge Montiel Meurer
Wayne Simmons
Jordi Onate
Emanuele Pavarotti


Pepsi – Penguin – “The Flight of the Penguin”

Andy Walker
Seth Gollub
James Dick
Spencer Leuders


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Video Game Trailer

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the pre-rendered visual effects within a Video Game Trailer. Game Trailers are defined as unique visual material created for the purpose of promoting an upcoming game release. To be eligible, the material in the Game Trailer must be pre-rendered and created for a promotional event, conference, in-store display or web distribution. The submission for this category must consist entirely of material from the Game Trailer as it was originally released.
Multiple entries from the same game title will only be allowed if the entries are from different Game Trailers and the submitting teams are entirely different, including the overall VFX Supervisor and overall VFX Producer.

The following are not eligible for this category:

  • Game Trailers that share any pre-rendered material with a video game currently
    released in stores or that contain re-purposed shots from previous trailers;
  • Game Trailers that contain real-time material from the game itself that totals more than 25% of the total running time of the Submission Length, not including Before & Afters; and
  • Animated commercials that originate as Broadcast material.

DJ Hero

Diarmid Harrison-Murray
Sarah Hiddlestone
Marco Puig
Jamie Jackson


HALO 3 – ODST – The Life (Winner)

Robert Moggach
Ryan Meredith
Jens Zalzala
Michael Pardee

Star Wars – The Old Republic

Tim Miller
Brandon Riza
Dave Wilson

Outstanding Real-Time Visual Effects in a Video Game

This award is to honor the overall achievement of real-time game engine-rendered visual effects within a video game for any game console, PC, or “next generation” platform. Submitted material may be any one, or combination of, the following:

  • Recorded real-time Game Play; and/or
  • A real-time game engine-rendered Cinematic that appears as part of the game.

Real-time is defined as predominantly 30 or greater frames per second NTSC and ATSC (US) HD video, or predominantly 25 or greater frames per second PAL and DVB (International) HD depending upon country of origination. Any imagery or action that does not meet this criterion is ineligible even if it was rendered in the game engine or in software. Any longer-than-real-time frames that are rendered in the game engine, later resized and/or reloaded, then played back in real-time from pre-rendered frames are ineligible as well.

Trailers or promos for games are not eligible in this category.

Call Of Duty – Modern Warfare 2 – Gulag Extraction (Winner)

Mark Rubin
Richard Kriegler
Robert Gaines
David Johnson

Fight Night Round 4 – Gameplay

Frank Vitz
Jenny Freeman
Jeff Atienza
Ben Ross


Need For Speed Shift – World Sequence

Andreas Moll
Sven Moll
Dave Flynn
Robert Dibley


Uncharted 2 – Among Thieves

Evan Wells
Christophe Balestra

Outstanding Created Environment in a Broadcast Program or Commercial

This award is to honor the overall achievement of a single created environment in a live action broadcast program that best creates an illusion of setting for the story being told. Created environments are defined as either completely artificial environments, or the enhancement of an existing practical set location through the addition of elements not present during photography. The environment may occur more than once in the project and under different conditions, but must be the same environment, created by the exact same team.

This category judges not only the techniques for creating the environment, but also their integration with any practical plate photography. Before & Afters must show the integration of the multiple elements used to create the environment.

Stereo extractions of environments that do not contain any other significant enhancements, or fully animated productions, are not eligible in this category. For practical purposes, the environment should be a single setting within the story, and not, for example, all locations within an entire city.

AMC Theaters / Coke – Magic Chairs

Rob Nederhorst
Dariush Derakhshani
Steve Cummings
Harry Michalakeas


Assassins Creed – Lineage – Ep. 1 “Duke of Milan Assassination”

Mathieu Lalonde
Nadine Homier
Joseph Kasparlan
Christian Morin

Flash Forward – Pilot “Freeway Overpass”

Steve Meyer
Colin Feist
Paul Ghezzo
Roger Kupelian

V – Pilot “Atrium and Ship Interiors” (Winner)

Chris Zapara
Chris Irving
David Morton
Trevor Adams


Outstanding Matte Paintings in a Feature Motion Picture

Avatar – Pandora (Winner)

Yvonne Muinde
Brenton Cottman
Peter Baustaedter
Jean-Luc Azzis


Franklyn – Meanwhile City Scapes

Tania Richard
Christoph Unger


Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince

Tania Richard
David Bassalla
Emily Cobb


Star Trek

Brett Northcutt
Shane Roberts
Masahiko Tani
Dan Wheaton


Outstanding Effects Animation in an Animated Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor the overall achievement of the effects animation within an entire animated motion picture. Effects animation constitutes any dynamic elements that are not characters, set pieces, or what would be considered a matte painting or background. These effects may include water, splashes, smoke, fire, other naturally occurring elements including dust and other particulates, as well as those animated using procedural techniques or dynamic simulations. The effects may or may not be photorealistic and they may interact with, or be part of the characters, set elements and matte paintings with which they coexist.

Cloudy With a Chance Of Meatballs

Rob Bredow
Dan Kramer
Matt Hausman
Carl Hooper


Coraline

John Allan Armstrong
Richard Kent Burton
Craig Dowsett


Monsters Vs. Aliens

Amaury Aubel
Scott Cegielski
Alain De Hoe
David Allen


Up (Winner)

Jason Johnston
Alexis Angelidis
Jon Reisch
Eric Froemling


Outstanding Matte Paintings in a Broadcast Program or Commercial

Kaiser Permanente – Emerald City (Winner)

Ben Walker
David Woodland
Kim Taylor
Ben Walsh


Outstanding Models and Miniatures in a Feature Motion Picture

Avatar – Samson/Home Tree / Floating Mountains / Ampsuit (Winner)

Simon Cheung
Paul Jenness
John Stevenson-Galvin
Rainer Zoettl


Coraline

Deborah Cook
Paul Mack
Martin Meunier
Matthew DeLeu


Night at The Museum – Battle of The Smithsonian – National Air and Space Museum Escape

Ian Hunter
Forest Fischer
Robert Chapin
Tony Chen

Terminator Salvation – Practical Models and Miniatures

Brian Gernand
Geoff Heron
Nick d’Abo
Patrick Sweeney

Outstanding Created Environment in a Feature Motion Picture

2012 – Los Angeles Destruction

Haarm-Pieter Duiker
Marten Larsson
Ryo Sakaguchi
Hanzhi Tang


Avatar – Floating Mountains

Dan Lemmon
Keith F. Miller
Cameron Smith
Jessica Cowley


Avatar – Jungle / Biolume (Winner)

Eric Saindon
Shadi Almassizadeh
Dan Cox
Ula Rademeyer


Avatar – Willow Glade

Guy Williams
Thelvin Cabezas
Daniel Macarin
Miae Kang


Outstanding Compositing in a Feature Motion Picture

This award is to honor outstanding achievement in compositing multiple elements into a final visual effect shot or group of shots in a live action feature motion picture. This category is for a body of work created for a single motion picture by an individual artist or team of artists.

Multiple entries from the same project are eligible provided the compositing teams are 100% different and the shots being submitted are completelydifferent. Title sequences are eligible as long as:

  • They are submitted in textless form in order not to conflict with any other awards rule; and
  • They are part of the storytelling and are not a specially designed separate animated title sequence in a live action project.

Animated films are not eligible in this category.

Avatar

Erik Winquist
Robin Hollander
Erich Eder
Giuseppe Tagliavini


Avatar – End Battle

Eddie Pasquarello
Beth D’Amato
Todd Vaziri
Jay Cooper


District 9 (Winner)

Shervin Shogian
Hamish Schumacher
Janeen Elliott
Simon Hughes


Sherlock Holmes – Wharf Explosion Sequence

Kate Windibank
Jan Adamczyk
Sam Osborne
Alex Cumming


Outstanding Compositing in a Broadcast Program or Commercial

This award is to honor outstanding achievement in compositing multiple elements into a final visual effect shot or group of shots in a single live action episode of a broadcast program or commercial. This category is for a body of work created for a single broadcast episode by an individual artist or team of artists. Multiple sequences may be entered from the same episode or series provided the compositing teams are 100% different and the shots being submitted are completely different.

Animated programs or main title sequences are not eligible in this category.

CSI Crime Scene Investigation – Ep. 1001 Opening Sequence (Winner)

Derek Smith
Christina Spring
Steve Meyer
Zach Zaubi


Kerry LowLow “Mouse” – Overall

Jake Mengers
Stephen Newbold
Kelly Bruce
Greg Howe-Davies


Pepsi – The Flight of the Penguin

Murray Butler
Ben Cronin
Andy Rowan-Robinson
Miyuki Shimamoto


Porsche – Family Tree

Tim Davies
Jeff Willette
Zach Tucker


Outstanding Visual Effects in a Student Project

Motherland

Hannes Appell


The Full Moon Mystery – The Discovery

David Goubitz
Flip Buttinger
Jeffrey De Vore


They Will Come To Town (Winner)

Thilo Ewers


URS – Cliff

Moritz Mayerhofer